×

‘Against Their Nature’: When Brazil Banned Women From Football

Dilma Mendes, does not remember how many times she was arrested as a kid. Her crime? Playing football in a country that banned women from the beautiful game for nearly four decades.


Women’s football coach Dilma Mendes, 59, poses for a picture at the Arena 2 de Julho Football School located in the city of Camacari, Bahia state, Brazil, on July 5, 2023.(Photo by RAFAEL MARTINS / AFP)

 

 

Dilma Mendes does not remember how many times she was arrested as a child. Her crime? Playing football in Brazil.

The country may be synonymous with the beautiful game, but it banned women from the sport for nearly four decades until 1979.

Ahead of the Women’s World Cup starting next week in Australia and New Zealand, where Brazil will be in action, Mendes recalled the lengths she went to in order to fulfill her dream of becoming a footballer.

As a girl in the 1970s, she gave ice cream to the boys she played with in Camacari in Brazil’s impoverished northeast in exchange for an early warning of the arrival of police busting girls flouting the prohibition.

 

Women’s football coach Dilma Mendes, 59, participates in a training session at the Arena 2 de Julho Football School located in the city of Camacari, Bahia state, Brazil, on July 5, 2023. (Photo by RAFAEL MARTINS / AFP)

 

She used to dig a hole next to the pitch to hide in until the enforcers left, then crawled out again to continue kicking the ball around with her male friends.

When they let her, which was not always the case.

Sometimes all her precautions failed and Mendes found herself hauled off to a police station.

“When I was a child I thought the police stopped those who did something wrong, and I didn’t feel like I was doing anything wrong,” Mendes, now 59, told AFP.

“The cops treated me well, but some said I couldn’t play because football was for men.”

Then-president Getulio Vargas promulgated a decree in 1941 to ban girls and women from football at a time many believed that participation in sport could inhibit childbearing ability.

The decree prohibited women from practising “sports incompatible with the conditions of their nature.”

No specific sanctions were mentioned, leaving it open to individual police officers to decide how to deal with offenders.

Football associations in other countries, such as Britain, Germany and France, also barred women from the sport, but Brazil’s ban was the only one decreed by law.

It remained in place until 1979.

While many like Mendes continued to play, the 38-year prohibition stunted development of the sport among Brazilian women during a period in which their male counterparts lifted three of their five World Cups.

 

Women’s football coach Dilma Mendes, 59, poses for a picture at the Arena 2 de Julho Football School located in the city of Camacari, Bahia state, Brazil, on July 5, 2023. (Photo by RAFAEL MARTINS / AFP)

 

– Beaten for playing –
The ban came at a socially conservative time when women were viewed as “maternal figures reserved for the domestic space” — a construct their presence on a sports field challenged head-on, said Brazilian sports researcher Silvana Goellner.

There are no records of women going to jail for violating the decree, but they would be detained and only released after questioning.

Many “never stopped playing” despite the threat of arrest, said Goellner, who co-authored a book on the topic. “They created strategies to circumvent the law.”

Some dressed as men, others played at night or in places hidden from public view. When busted, they scattered in different directions to confuse their pursuers.

But many were unable to evade a reckoning much closer to home: their families.

Mendes remembers sitting at the police station praying that her father — who supported her passion — would be the one to fetch her.

If it was her mother, she could count on a hiding for practising a “men’s sport,” said the youngest of seven siblings — five of them boys.

“It was hard to arrive home and your mother and brothers beat you and the next day you have to be ready to play again,” Mendes recalled.

“I saw many friends leave football because of that cruel process.”

But she never gave up, making a modest career in futsal — a variation of football played on a small court, often indoors — and in professional football when it was officially opened to women in Brazil in 1983 amid growing calls for equal rights.

 

Players pose for a picture with their feet on balls during a training session led by women’s football coach Dilma Mendes, 59, at the Arena 2 de Julho Football School located in the city of Camacari, Bahia state, Brazil, on July 5, 2023.(Photo by RAFAEL MARTINS / AFP)

 

– Never had a chance –
After retiring as a player in 1995, Mendes moved into coaching and helped unearth Formiga, a legendary former midfielder for the Brazil women’s team.

She also coached Brazil’s women to victory in the seven-a-side world championship in 2019.

Brazil had “great players” who never had a chance, Mendes lamented in hindsight of the “cruel” ban, which has also meant a very patchy historic record of women’s football in the South American country.

But things have changed, and now the “Selecao” are preparing to participate in their ninth Women’s World Cup.

They will run out under veteran captain Marta, who has scored more World Cup goals (17) than any other player, man or woman.

Brazil’s best showing in the event, first staged in 1991, was in 2007 when they were beaten in the final by Germany.